![]() |
![]() ![]() ![]() ![]() ![]() ![]() ![]() ![]() ![]() ![]() ![]() ![]() ![]() Français |
Global
Integrity
Report lowers Canadian
federal government's score from 80 to 75 -- Weak
enforcement of Accountability
Act's
loophole-filled rules the main reason for drop in
democracy rating Wednesday, May 4, 2011 OTTAWA - Today, Global
Integrity released its 2010
Global Integrity
Report which dropped Canada
from 11th to 19th out of the almost 100 countries
evaluated since 2007. The Report is the world's
most
comprehensive, detailed assessment (using more than 300
indicators) of
national government accountability, integrity and
democratic process,
and measures the strength of key laws and enforcement
records up to the
end of 2010. "As the Global
Integrity
Report makes clear, Canada's federal government
has significant loopholes in its democratic process
and government
accountability systems when
compared to other countries, and weak enforcement in
many areas, and so
has a lot of work to do to become the
world's leading democracy," said Duff Conacher,
Lead Researcher
for the Canada report, and Coordinator of
Democracy Watch and Assistant Coordinator of the Democracy
Education Network. "Government
integrity continues to be undermined by loopholes that
allow for
dishonesty, secret
donations to some candidates and to political party
trust funds,
conflicts of interest by policy-makers, excessive
government
secrecy, secret, unethical lobbying, and is also
undermined by
Cabinet
patronage appointments, arbitrary election calls and a
flawed voting
system, and lack of Prime Minister, judicial and
Senate accountability and
weak whistleblower protection and government
accountability lapdog
agencies." "Democracy Watch and the good government coalitions it coordinates call on all federal parties in the new Parliament to pass a Real Accountability Act to close the dozens of undemocratic and accountability loopholes in the federal government," said Conacher.
Each national government is assessed by Global
Integrity’s
in-country
experts by providing answers to Global Integrity’s more
than 300
questions in its
Integrity Indicators Scorecard. The Scorecard is
divided into six
categories (with 23 sub-categories in total), as
follows: I.
Non-Governmental Organizations,
Public Information and Media; II. Elections; III.
Government Conflicts
of Interest Safeguards and Checks and Balances; IV.
Public
Administration and Professionalism; V. Government
Oversight and
Controls; VI. Anti-Corruption Legal Framework, Judicial
Impartiality,
and Law Enforcement Professionalism.
None of the national governments that have been
assessed
since 2007 have received a "Very Strong" above 90
rating. In
Canada, increasing problems with government secrecy and
weak
enforcement of key
ethics and government accountability laws,
as well as
the 2008 arbitrary election call and the
arbitrary 2008 and 2009 shutdowns of Parliament,
have lowered Canada's federal government from the
high-"Moderate" score
of 80 in 2008 to the mid-Moderate
rating of 75 in 2010. Overall, the main problem with Canada's federal
government is
that while it has enacted almost all the laws needed for
an effective
government integrity system (and so receives a Strong
overall score of
90 for its Legal Framework), loopholes and flaws in the
laws, and weak
enforcement, undermine the system (so that Canada
received Weak overall
score of 61 for its implementation of the laws). Canada
has its worst scores in the following categories and
sub-categories:
See for more details on Democracy Watch's website:
[NOTE: See also Democracy Watch's 2010
Report
Card on the Federal Conservatives' Accountability and
Democratic Reform
Record which details the federal Conservatives' 39
broken promises
in the loophole-filled, so-called "Federal
Accountability Act" (FAA)
and other measures which, along with the inaction of
past Liberal and
Conservative federal governments, have left 100
undemocratic and accountability loopholes and flaws in
the federal
government's accountability
and decision-making systems (To see a summary of
the 100
loopholes, click
here)]. [NOTE: See also
Democracy Watch's news release about the May 2010
report of the Oliphant
Inquiry into the Mulroney-Schreiber affair, to which the
Conservative
government has still not responded.] - 30 - For more information, contact: Democracy Watch's Clean Up the System webpage |