[Democracy Watch Logo]



 
Media Release

FEDERAL NDP HAS BEST CORPORATE RESPONSIBILITY PLATFORM, 
GREENS AND BLOC NOT TOO FAR BEHIND, 
CONSERVATIVE AND LIBERAL GRADES MUCH WORSE 
-- MANY KEY GAPS IN ALL PARTIES' PLATFORMS
-- LACK OF HONESTY-IN-POLITICS LAW MEANS
NONE OF THE PARTIES' PLEDGES SHOULD BE TRUSTED

Thursday, January 19, 2006

OTTAWA - Today, Democracy Watch released its Report Card on the 2006 Corporate Responsibility Election Platforms of the five main federal political parties (See Report Card set out below).

The Report Card grades the five main parties' platform pledges in eight areas covering a total of about 15 changes that Democracy Watch believes are the changes that will most effectively require federally regulated corporations to act honestly, ethically, openly, efficiently, representatively and, if they don't act in these democratic ways, easily and thoroughly held accountable.  Of course, there are many other measures, especially for specific industry sectors, that need to be enacted by the federal government to ensure fully responsible corporations.

The measures are a compilation of the proposals of two nation-wide coalitions Democracy Watch coordinates (Canadian Community Reinvestment Coalition and the Corporate Responsibility Coalition).  A combined total of more than 100 citizen groups with a total membership of more than 3 million Canadians belong to the coalitions, groups that work on anti-poverty, bank accountability, community economic development, consumer, corporate responsibility, environment, labour, social justice, women and youth issues.

Many national surveys over the past several years have shown that a large majority of Canadians support the corporate responsibility reforms set out in the Report Card, as do many commentators on corporate responsibility.

The eight measures all reflect the following five key elements for ensuring that large, powerful corporations act responsibly and follow rules: 1. strong laws with no loopholes; 2. requirement to disclose violations; 3. fully independent, fully empowered watchdog agencies to enforce laws; 4. penalties that are high enough to encourage compliance; and 5. empowerment of citizens to hold corporations and watchdog agencies accountable.

The parties were given a grade ranging from A (Platform makes clear promise to implement proposal) to I (Platform does not mention proposal), with grades B for a vague or partial promise to implement the proposal, C and D for clear to vague promises to explore the proposal, E for mentioning proposal and F for mentioning the theme of the proposal.  Grades were added up to calculate the overall grades.

The highlights of the Report Card are as follows:

  • The NDP had the best overall grade of B- (mainly because of many wide-ranging proposals, including bank accountability and whistleblower protection pledges), with the Green Party close behind with a C, and the Bloc Québécois third with a D+;
  • The Conservatives with an overall E- and Liberals with an overall F had far worse platforms than the other three parties;
  • While all of the parties plan to strengthen corporate responsibility requirements for some corporate sectors, none of the parties have a comprehensive plan that covers all of the sectors regulated by the federal government (with the NDP coming closest to a comprehensive plan);
  • All of the parties except the Liberals pledge to increase the independence and expertise of the heads of government agencies that regulate corporations, and;
  • Two key gaps in all the platforms are that:
    • none of the parties pledge to empower citizens and citizen groups to hold corporations directly accountable (for example, by using a proposed low-cost, effective method that will ensure the formation of broad-based, well-resourced citizen watchdog groups for many industry sectors -- For details, go to Democracy Watch's Citizen Association Campaign webpage), and;
    • none of the parties pledge to ensure that corporate wrongdoing is regularly exposed in an easily accessible way so that consumers and investors can make fully informed decisions.
"Key gaps in all the parties' corporate responsibility platforms means that the next federal government will likely not do nearly enough to help consumers and investors hold large corporations accountable, nor to help them make fully informed buying and investing decisions," said Duff Conacher, Coordinator of Democracy Watch. "And no voter should trust that the parties will even act on their limited pledges, given the lack of a federal honesty-in-politics law."

The 2006 Report Card is an updated version of the Report Card issued by Democracy Watch during the 2004 federal election, reflecting changes that have occurred in federal laws since 2004.  In the Corporate Responsibility area of the 2004 Report Card, the NDP received the highest overall grade of B mainly because of its promises to press for many of the enforcement measures covered in that area of the Report Card.

Democracy Watch graded the parties' election platforms by reviewing the platforms.  Statements by party leaders or representatives were not taken into account as they are not fully accessible to all voters, nor are they binding in any way on the party (as admitted by many party leaders) and as a result are even less reliable than promises made in the parties' platforms.  (Please see Backgrounder set out below)

- 30 -

FOR MORE INFORMATION, CONTACT:
Duff Conacher, Coordinator
Tel: (613) 241-5179
dwatch@web.net

Democracy Watch's Federal Election Campaign webpage

Bloc Québécois platform webpage
Conservative Party of Canada platform webpage
Green Party of Canada platform webpage
Liberal Party of Canada platform webpage
NDP platform webpage


Report Card on the 2006 Corporate Responsibility
Election Platforms of the Federal Political Parties

See Backgrounder set out below for details about parties' platforms

GRADING SYSTEM
A - Platform makes clear promise to implement proposal
B - Platform makes vague or partial promise to implement proposal
C - Platform makes clear promise to explore proposal
D - Platform makes vague or partial promise to explore proposal
E - Platform mentions proposal
F - Platform mentions theme of proposal
I - Platform does not mention proposal



Bloc Québécois platform webpage
Conservative Party of Canada platform webpage
Green Party of Canada platform webpage
Liberal Party of Canada platform webpage
NDP platform webpage

OVERALL REPORT CARD GRADES
Bloc Québécois - D+
Conservative Party - E-
Green Party - C
Liberal Party - F
New Democrat Party - B-


 1. Facilitating citizen watchdog groups over corporations
 2. Requiring corporations to address stakeholder concerns
 3. Making corporate watchdog agencies more independent and effective
 4. Ensuring loophole-free laws and strong penalties for wrongdoers
 5. Exposing corporate wrongdoing
 6. Penalizing corporate wrongdoing
 7. Ensuring effective whistleblower protection
 8. Increasing bank accountability


 
1. Facilitating citizen watchdog groups over corporations - Require federal government institutions and federally regulated corporate sectors to enclose one-page pamphlets periodically in their mailings to citizens inviting citizens to join citizen-funded and directed groups to represent citizen interests in policy-making and enforcement processes of key government departments (for example, on ethics, spending, and health care) and key federal corporate sectors (airlines, telecommunications, banks and other financial institutions, shareholder rights) as has been done in the U.S. and recommended for Canadian banks and other financial institutions in 1998 by a federal task force, a House of Commons Committee, and a Senate Committee.  (Go to Citizen Association Campaign for details about Democracy Watch's proposals)
Bloc Québécois - B-
Conservative Party - I
Green Party - F
Liberal Party - I
New Democrat Party - I
2. Requiring corporations to address stakeholder concerns - Require all federally regulated corporations to take into account the interests of all stakeholders when making decisions and undertaking activities, and to account publicly how they have done so.  (Go to Corporate Responsibility Campaign for details about Democracy Watch's proposals)
Bloc Québécois - B-
Conservative Party - C-
Green Party - A-
Liberal Party - C+
New Democrat Party - A-
3. Making corporate watchdog agencies more independent and effective - Make all watchdog agencies for corporations (for example: CRTC, Financial Consumer Agency of Canada, Canadian Transportation Agency) more independent from Cabinet by giving opposition party leaders a veto over appointees, and more effective by giving them them adequate resources, and full powers to investigate allegations of violations and to penalize violators.  (Go to Corporate Responsibility Campaign for details about Democracy Watch's proposals)
Bloc Québécois - B-
Conservative Party - B-
Green Party - B-
Liberal Party - I
New Democrat Party - B
4. Ensuring loophole-free laws and strong penalties for wrongdoers - Close any technical and other loopholes that have been identified in laws, regulations, policies, codes, guidelines and rules (especially those regulating large corporations) to help ensure strong enforcement, and increase financial penalties for violations to a level that significantly effects the annual revenues/budget of the corporation.  (Go to Corporate Responsibility Campaign for details about Democracy Watch's proposals)
Bloc Québécois - B+
Conservative Party - C-
Green Party - B+
Liberal Party - C
New Democrat Party - B+
5. Exposing corporate wrongdoing - Require all federally regulated corporations to disclose all convictions and settlements for violations of laws, regulations, policies, codes, guidelines or rules on an easily accessible, searchable, government-maintained website, so that consumers and investors can more easily make fully informed choices in the marketplace.  (Go to Corporate Responsibility Campaign for details about Democracy Watch's proposals)
Bloc Québécois - I
Conservative Party - I
Green Party - I
Liberal Party - I
New Democrat Party - I
6. Penalizing corporate wrongdoing - Prohibit all corporations that violate domestic or international laws, regulations, policies, codes, guidelines or rules from receiving any federal government contracts, grants, subsidies, investments, customs/trade status, tax credits or deductions.  (Go to Corporate Responsibility Campaign for details about Democracy Watch's proposals)
Bloc Québécois - I
Conservative Party - F-
Green Party - B
Liberal Party - I
New Democrat Party - B


7. Ensuring effective whistleblower protection - Require everyone to report any violation of any law, regulation, policy, code, guideline or rule, and give all watchdog agencies for corporations (for example: CRTC, Financial Consumer Agency of Canada, Canadian Transportation Agency) full powers to protect anyone who reports a violation (so-called "whistleblowers") from retaliation, and to reward whistleblowers whose allegations are proven to be true.  (Go to Corporate Responsibility Campaign for details about Democracy Watch's proposals)

Bloc Québécois - C
Conservative Party - I
Green Party - B-
Liberal Party - D
New Democrat Party - B+


8. Increasing bank accountability - Require banks and trust companies to prove that their service charges and credit card interest rates do not amount to gouging, to disclose details about their service, lending and investment activities so that discriminatory patterns can be revealed and corrected (as in the U.S. - this requirement must also be applied to the federal government's financial institutions such as the Business Development Bank of Canada (BDC), Export Development Canada, Techonology Partnerships Fund and the regional investment funds), and to prove that branch closures are justified; and don't allow any bank or trust company to grow larger through mergers or takeovers if their record is poor.   (Go to Bank Accountability Campaign for details about Democracy Watch's proposals)

Bloc Québécois - B-
Conservative Party - I
Green Party - I
Liberal Party - I
New Democrat Party - B-
Top

Top of Report Card




 
 
Background Details for the
Report Card on the 2006 Corporate Responsibility
Election Platforms of the Federal Political Parties
(Set out below are quotations from the federal parties' platform documents (with page # included)
upon which the Report Card grades were based for each of the 8 measures graded)

Bloc Québécois platform webpage
Conservative Party of Canada platform webpage
Green Party of Canada platform webpage
Liberal Party of Canada platform webpage
NDP platform webpage


OVERALL REPORT CARD GRADES
Bloc Québécois - D+
Conservative Party - E-
Green Party - C
Liberal Party - F
New Democrat Party - B-


 1. Facilitating citizen watchdog groups over corporations
 2. Requiring corporations to address stakeholder concerns
 3. Making corporate watchdog agencies more independent and effective
 4. Ensuring loophole-free laws and strong penalties for wrongdoers
 5. Exposing corporate wrongdoing
 6. Penalizing corporate wrongdoing
 7. Ensuring effective whistleblower protection
 8. Increasing bank accountability


1. Facilitating citizen watchdog groups over corporations - Require federally regulated corporate sectors to enclose one-page pamphlets periodically in their mailings to citizens inviting citizens to join citizen-funded and directed groups to represent citizen interests in policy-making and enforcement processes of key federal corporate sectors (airlines, telecommunications, banks and other financial institutions, shareholder rights) as has been done in the U.S. and recommended for Canadian banks and other financial institutions in 1998 by a federal task force, a House of Commons Committee, and a Senate Committee.  (Go to Citizen Association Campaign for details about Democracy Watch's proposals)

Bloc Québécois - I
- Nothing related to proposal in platform

Conservative Party - I
- Nothing related to proposal in platform

Green Party - F
- "94. Ensure adequate funding for national organizations such as National Action Committee and other bodies committed to improving the status of women." (p.18)

Liberal Party -  I
- Nothing related to proposal in platform

New Democrat Party - I
- Nothing related to proposal in platform
 

2. Requiring corporations to address stakeholder concerns - Require all federally regulated corporations to take into account the interests of all stakeholders when making decisions and undertaking activities, and to account publicly how they have done so.  (Go to Corporate Responsibility Campaign for details about Democracy Watch's proposals)

Bloc Québécois - B-
- "Le Bloc Québécois demande au gouvernement fédéral de prendre, dès que le Tribunal canadien du commerce extérieur l’en aura autorisé, des mesures de sauvegarde pour protéger l’industrie du meuble des importations chinoises." (p.74)
 - "Le Bloc Québécois continuera à exiger l'instauration d'un programme de soutien au revenu pour les travailleurs âgés sur le modèle de l’ancien PATA." (p.77)
- "Le Bloc Québécois presse le gouvernement fédéral de réviser ses positions dans les négociations commerciales pour faire en sorte d’inclure dans les accords commerciaux des clauses prévoyant le respect de règles minimales en terme de droit du travail, de respect des droits de la personne et de l’environnement." (p.78)
- "Le Bloc Québécois considère que le Canada, pour être crédible sur cette question, doit rapidement signer les grandes conventions de l'Organisation internationale du travail contre les discriminations, le travail forcé et le travail des enfants, pour le droit d'association syndicale et la libre négociation." (p.78)
- "Le Bloc Québécois enjoint le gouvernement fédéral de revoir ses programmes de soutien économique afin de les rendre concrètement accessibles et de les adapter aux besoins spécifiques des entreprises d'économie sociale et des coopératives." (p.82)
- "Le Bloc Québécois demandera au gouvernement fédéral de s'inspirer des mesures fiscales québécoises applicables aux coopératives et insistera sur l'adoption de deux mesures visant à encourager les membres et les employés à investir dans la capitalisation de leur coopérative : l'instauration d'une déduction fiscale pour les investissements dans les parts coopératives et l'autorisation du report de l'impôt sur les ristournes que les sociétaires laissent dans leur coopérative." (p.83)
 - "Le Bloc Québécois déposera à nouveau un projet de loi anti-briseurs de grève à la Chambre des communes et reviendra à la charge tant qu’il ne sera pas adopté." (p.115)
- "Le Bloc Québécois demande que soit remplacer le modèle existant d’équité salariale reposant sur des plaintes par une nouvelle loi distincte et proactive en matière d’équité salariale qui ferait de l’équité salariale un droit fondamental de la personne conformément à ce qui existe au Québec." (p.116)
- "Le Bloc Québécois s'engage à déposer un projet de loi qui obligera les entreprises de téléphonie et de communications à offrir tous les services partout sur le territoire qu'elles desservent." (p.143)

Conservative Party - C-
- "A Conservative government will: - Develop a Clean Air Act to legislate the reduction of smog-causing pollutants such as Nitrogen Oxides (NOx), Sulphur Dioxide (SO2), and particulate matter. - Address the issue of greenhouse gas emissions, such as carbon dioxide (CO2), with a made-in-Canada plan, emphasising new technologies, developed in concert with the provinces and in coordination with other major industrial countries. - Ensure water quality by addressing environmental issues such as the need for aquifer mapping, protection of the Great Lakes Basin, banning interbasin water transfers, imposing substantial penalties for illegal bilge oil dumping, and ensuring adequate watershed management and methods to ensure water quality and quantity. - Clean up federal contaminated sites and encourage the private sector to clean up brownfields. - Require 5 percent average renewable content in Canadian gasoline and diesel fuel, such as ethanol and biodiesel, by 2010." (p.37)

Green Party - A-
- "1. Eliminate the use of the most dangerous toxic chemicals by 2008. 2. Prohibit the use of pesticides for cosmetic purposes. 3. Make industry accountable for its chemicals and impose significant pollution taxes on harmful chemicals until they can be eliminated. 4. Regulate chemicals in consumer products through the Canadian Environmental Protection Act (CEPA). 5. Mandate a CEPA taskforce to focus on pollution reduction in the Great Lakes basin. 6. Create a Clean Canada Fund to clean up toxic sites. 7. Re-focus the Canadian Environmental Protection Act on pollution prevention. 8. Ban the incineration of imported toxic waste." (p.5)
- "9. Enact product stewardship legislation that would require wood producers to increase the life span of their products and to assume the full recycling and disposal costs of products. 10. Work with provinces, First Nations and the logging industry to create federal standards and best practices that ensure the sustainability of our forests. 12. In collaboration with the provinces and territories, pursue Forest Stewardship Council (FSC) certification of all forestry conditional upon compliance to its 10 principles on crown lands and encourage the same on private lands." (p.6)
- "16. Stop any and all bulk water exports by renegotiating or saying no to trade deals that allow corporations to strip our watersheds of freshwater and disrupt entire ecosystems. 17. Amend the Charter of Rights and Freedoms to enshrine the right of future Canadians to an ecological heritage that includes breathable air and drinkable water. 18. Restore ecosystem health to Canada's coastline and inland watersheds by funding improvements to municipal wastewater treatment systems, with particular emphasis on ensuring shoreline communities and industries stop dumping untreated waste into rivers, lakes and oceans." (p.7)
- "19. Rescind all uranium-mining permits and prohibit the export of fissionable nuclear material. 20. Promote life-cycle product stewardship of metals to ensure that once mined, they remain in economic service for generations. 21. End all subsidies to the mining sector to ensure full-cost accounting. 22. Work with provinces, territories and industry to ensure that all mining operations are insured for environmental liabilities and have an adequate pre-funded plan for remediation when the mine closes. 23. Introduce and regulate the mining industry under an International Corporate Social Responsibility Act." (p.8)
- "34. Shift taxes on fossil fuels to earlier stages in the production cycle to encourage competition among companies to lower operating costs while reducing emissions. 35. Increase emission reduction targets for large industrial emitters to at least 55 Megatonnes above and beyond other policies and measures that reduce
industrial emissions. 36. Targets should be based on actual emissions, not emissions intensity per unit of production, and all data should be available for public scrutiny. 37. Expand the proposed National Emissions Trading System so that it will ensure real emission reductions across sectors. 38. Use revenue from tradable pollution permits to offset tax breaks for increasing energy efficiency and industry initiatives that reduce fuel consumption." (pp.9-10)
- "43. Legislate stronger, more effective antitrust laws in concentrated industry sectors." (p.11)
- "46. Sign and implement the Cartagena Protocol on Biosafety, ensuring that the adoption of new products is guided by the precautionary principle, which balances the economic benefits of innovation with public health and ecological integrity. 47. Strengthen and enforce Canada's Species at Risk Act in partnership with the provinces and territories to protect all species at risk and their habitats." (p.12)
- "53. Ban bottom dragging and lead efforts for a global ban on harmful fishing practices." (p.12)
- "54. Support local, provincial and territorial genetically engineered free zones and pass legislation requiring labeling of genetically engineered foods." (p.12)
- "58. Reform the regulatory environment of agriculture to challenge corporate concentration, eliminate international dumping and subsidies, and continue to allow seed saving by farmers." (p.13)
- "63. Pass a law that forbids the patenting of life forms and makes biotech developers of genetically engineered crops liable for damage such crops might cause." (p.13)
- "71. Enforce a mandatory target of 25 per cent better fuel efficiency for the automobile industry and increase standards over the next 5 years." (p.14)
- "84. Develop tax incentives for companies to meet the highest standards of gender and pay equity. 86. Implement full pay equity for women employed in the federal sector. 87. Sign the UN's global initiative for the elimination of discrimination and violence against women, and review Canada's performance to ensure it becomes and remains a world leader in fighting discrimination and violence against women. 90. Make eliminating institutional racism a top priority of Status of Women Canada's strategy to end violence and abuse facing Aboriginal women. 92. Mandate the CRTC to regulate and receive complaints about the advertising industry." (pp.17-18)
- "128. Provide incentives for companies to reduce stress in the workplace and promote emotional health. 129. Increase taxes on tobacco products, alcohol and junk food. 130. Rapidly reduce the release of carcinogens, mutagens, neurotoxins and endocrine-disrupting chemicals into the food chain. 131. Introduce mandatory labelling of all foods containing genetically modified organisms. 132. Ban the sub-therapeutic use of agricultural antibiotics and hormones. 137. Ban all non-natural pesticides and insecticides by the year 2010 and provide alternatives for farmers. 141. Prohibit reproductive cloning and require a Health Canada license for any organization or institution that performs genetic manipulation for commercial or scientific purposes." (p.24)
- "147. Create a "Comprehensive Anti-Poverty Strategy for Canada," which will: - Toughen regulations to ensure fair treatment and better wage standards for all working Canadians. . . 149. Enforce measures to ensure that corporate pension plans are adequately funded. 151. Create tax incentives for businesses to implement flexible schedules and on-site childcare. 152. Implement a managed reduction in the standard workweek to thirty-five work hours per week. 158. Combat racism in hiring practices and give greater recognition to foreign qualifications." (pp.25-26)
- "206. Support the provision of royalty-free and low-cost AIDS medicines for Africa, Asia and South America." (p.33)
- "207. Work with other nations to eliminate unsustainable fishing in international waters and create a system of marine sanctuaries. Press for custodial management of fish stocks on the Grand Banks." (p.33)
- "215. Renegotiate our multilateral trade agreements, such as NAFTA and the upcoming FTAA, to include fair trade tariffs that work to protect human rights and our ecosystems, as well as terminate investor-state dispute mechanisms that erode Canada's sovereignty and environmental laws. 216. Propose a reform of the WTO, the IMF and the World Bank, placing these institutions under the authority of the UN general assembly, and shift the direction of international trade away from "free trade" to "fair trade" focusing on the global protection of human rights, labour standards, cultural diversity, and ecosystems." (p.34)

Liberal Party - C+
- "Positioning Canada in Global Business Networks: The Liberal government will invest almost $500 million over the next five years to implement CAN-Trade, a comprehensive network of services and programs. This new trade promotion strategy will better position Canadian firms, particularly small and medium-sized enterprises, in China, India and other priority markets. Highlights include: . . . - A Corporate Social Responsibility Centre which, in partnership with the private sector, will help ensure that Canadian activities in emerging markets foster social and environmental as well as economic goals; and - The Sustainable Cities Initiative, which links Canadian companies to opportunities for improving the sustainability of major cities in developing nations." (pp.47-48)
- "In April 2005, the Martin government released Moving Forward on Climate Change which details an ambitious strategy to meet Canada’s Kyoto protocol commitments by reducing “greenhouse gases,” like CO2 and methane, that are the main culprits behind global warming. Key measures include: - The Climate Fund - A $1 billion market-based institution will buy “emission reduction credits” from businesses, farmers, and others who invest to cut greenhouse gas generation in their activities. - The Partnership Fund, which will allow us to work with provinces and territories to meet our climate change objectives through support for large strategic projects that result in significant emission reductions. Funding of $2 to $3 billion will be made available over 10 years. - Regulatory measures that will establish “caps” on emissions by large industries and a 25% reduction target for automakers." (p.65)
 - "CLEAN AIR: Our climate change plan is improving air quality across Canada, with associated benefits for health and quality of life. A Liberal government will do more to ensure clean air through the following measures: - Monitoring and standards - Expand air quality monitoring and reporting through the new Air Quality Index. It will provide Canadians with the information needed to protect their health. We will complement this by developing national air emission standards for smog-forming pollutants and toxic emissions and will work with the US to upgrade our joint air quality agreement. We will also lead the way in the UN Environmental Program initiative to develop a Global Mercury Reduction Agreement with key countries such as China. - Renewable fuels standard - Introduce in cooperation with provinces and territories, a National Renewable Fuels Standard requiring, within five years, an average 5% renewable fuels content (e.g., biofuels like ethanol) in all gasoline and diesel fuel sold in Canada. We will maintain the excise tax exemption for biofuels. This initiative will contribute to cleaner air while stimulating a new biofuels industry in Canada and creating an important new market for farmers. CLEAN WATER: The National Ecosystem Initiative and Revitalization Plan: A Liberal government, supported by the provinces, banned the bulk removal of water from Canada’s watersheds. Those watersheds require our on-going stewardship. If re-elected, a Liberal government will implement a 10-year, $1 billion National Ecosystem Initiative and Revitalization Plan. The Plan covers the world’s largest freshwater ecosystem, the Great Lakes-St. Lawrence River basin, as well as other key waterways under stress, including the Lake Winnipeg watershed. It will include actions to identify and restore the significantly threatened ecosystems that incorporate our waterways. These ecological systems are home to well over half of Canada’s population and generate 75 per cent of Canada’s manufacturing output and 25 per cent of agricultural activity. The National Ecosystem Initiative builds on federal, provincial, and municipal sharedcost programs such as the Great Lakes Action Plan and the St.Lawrence Action Plan. While these initiatives have made a significant difference in many areas, more needs to be done to deal with key threats to our foremost ecosystems. The National Ecosystem Initiative will restore the areas contaminated by past actions - such as industrial toxins in the water and sediment, lost habitat, contaminated fish and wildlife - and keep pace with growth and development by addressing increased discharges from a higher population, intensive agricultural use, and new challenges such as nonpoint source contamination from the use of pharmaceuticals. The government will continue to address point-source pollution from industrial discharges into the water through federal regulations such as Canadian Environmental Protection Act and the Fisheries Act." (pp.66-67)
- "The Montreal Action Plan on Climate Change: The Liberal government invited the world to Canada as the host of the recently concluded United Nations Conference on Climate Change: Montreal 2005, because it understands that Canada must assume its international responsibilities if we are to address the environmental challenges that face this country and the world as a whole. This successful conference brought together over 180 countries to create the Montreal Action Plan, a road map for the world’s future approach to cooperation on climate change. As Canada’s Presidency of the United Nations Framework Convention on Climate Change continues through 2006, a Liberal government would lead the implementation of this plan." (p.68)

New Democrat Party - A-
- "Cut wasteful and inefficient spending on tax giveaways to large corporations, where those funds are given away without requiring that a single job be created, a single person trained, or a single dollar invested. We will stop the $10 billion in waste in this area proposed by the Liberals in their November 2005 election platform “economic statement”." (p.4)
- "Revitalizing and building on the national Employment Insurance Program — in consultation with provincial, territorial governments and labour and management EI partners - to make EI a key resource for public training strategies and programs." (p.8)
- "Stop further privatization and protect public health care from being dismantled and privatized. . . . Reduce health costs to families, by phasing in a national prescription drug program." (p.10)
- "Building on the offer of the provinces and territories and work together towards the establishment of a national prescription drug plan, which would be phased in beginning with coverage for key catastrophic drug costs and gradually expanding coverage, as finances permit, until the plan is universal in application. - Beginning by phasing out the evergreening of patent drugs so cheaper generic drugs can come to market sooner. And the ban on direct-to-consumer advertising of pharmaceuticals so there is less unnecessary prescribing of drug therapies." (p.12)
- "Jack Layton and the NDP will work to introduce and pass three major laws that will crack down on big polluters and help guarantee a cleaner environment for current and future generations. - Clean Water Act: to establish national standards and protection for drinking water, including those jurisdictions under federal control such as First Nations reserves. Water quality regulations under this law would include standards for solid waste disposal, dump management, mine site operations and rehabilitation, forestry and farming practices, and pesticide use. - Clean Air Act: to set and pursue a target that lives up to our responsibilities to the Kyoto Accord to address air pollution. . . . The NDP’s Clean Air Act will undo the damage caused by Liberal neglect and set a firm target - by 2020, Canada’s greenhouse gas emissions will be 25% below what they were in 1990. - Polluter Pay and Toxic Pollution Reduction Act: to overhaul the Canadian Environmental Protection Act - Canada’s national pollution law - to introduce the polluter pays concept and to replace the current emphasis on voluntary action with mandatory pollution prevention measures." (p.13)
- "Fight smog by implementing a green car strategy: ? Encourage the manufacturing of lower or zero-emission vehicles in Canada, the kind of new models we need to keep auto plants open. - Establish mandatory vehicle emission standards, opposed by the Liberals, applicable to all vehicles and modeled on the tough California emissions standards. - Provide financial incentives for purchasers of alternative-fuel vehicles, support the development of a domestic market and domestic R&D and component production." (p.17)
- "Protect the moratorium against drilling for oil off the coast of British Columbia, and oppose drilling for oil in the Great Lakes." (p.17)
- "We favour respecting consumers’ right to know through mandatory labelling of genetically modified organisms (GMOs)." (p.19)
- "Reassert strong leadership on Great Lakes protection issues, beginning with a strong position on the re-negotiation with the United States of the Great Lakes Water Quality Agreement." (p.19)
- "Commit to sustaining Canada’s ancient forests for future generations. The NDP will work with provincial and territorial governments, stakeholders, forest communities, First Nations, and environmentalists to protect Canada’s large intact forests (such as the Boreal Forest) and include adequate preserves, and that sustainable forest management be practiced." (p.19)
- "Improve Canada’s environmental rules regarding endangered species so that politics does not trump best available science when it comes to our responsibility for species that are at risk." (p.19)
- "Transforming NAFTA in order to achieve a fair trade policy. Deeper economic integration with the United States is not working for Canada. In light of recent and on-going trade disputes, the time has come for the parties to NAFTA to take a new look at the treaty, and to find ways to make it work in the cause of fair trade. We favour elimination of Chapter 11 (which, in our view, unreasonably limits Canada’s sovereignty in regulating investment). We also favour changes to address the serious shortcomings of the treaty provisions on energy and water. These issues require a broad consensus ? and there is a striking consensus emerging about them across Canada. To build on this growing consensus, we favour a public review of every aspect of the impact of NAFTA on the Canadian economy and Canadian public policy including tariffs, dispute resolution, energy, corporate regulation and ownership and culture." (p.28)
- "Bring balance to the Canadian International Trade Tribunal to include the interests of workers and communities as well as businesses." (p.29)
- "Working with farmers to ensure the right to save and reuse seed. The right to reuse seed will be a fundamental principle of Canada’s international aid development." (p.29)
- "Ensure fair wages and working standards, including: - Increasing the minimum wage to $10 an hour for workers under federal jurisdiction. - As an important step towards fairness for women, implementing the recommendations in the Pay Equity Task Force Final Report. - Implementing federal laws to outlaw replacement workers in strikes or lockouts in areas of federal jurisdiction, something the Liberals oppose." (p.31)
- "Introduce legislation to create an independent watchdog on oil and gas prices that will report to Parliament, to help protect against future gouging by the big gas and oil companies." (p.31)
- "Strengthen Canada’s homegrown film and television production by: - Directing the CRTC to require clear, binding, monitored and enforced performance standards for broadcasters, including a significant and permanent increase in the production and broadcast of Canadian drama." (p.32)
- "Protecting pensions by: - Implementing a pension benefits insurance system for employees under federal jurisdiction, and invite provincial and territorial governments to join the system. - Building on the success of the NDP’s Wage Earner Protection Act (Bill C-55) and introduce amendments to Canada’s bankruptcy laws to put the economic interests of workers first. This would give both severance pay and unfunded pension liabilities priority in the allocation of corporate assets in bankruptcy. - Ensuring that workers’ pensions are protected by introducing changes to eliminate the practice of employer-contribution holidays and to tighten the rules to prevent employer underfunding of pension plans." (p.37)
 

3. Making corporate watchdog agencies more independent and effective - Make all watchdog agencies for corporations (for example: CRTC, Financial Consumer Agency of Canada, Canadian Transportation Agency) more independent from Cabinet by giving opposition party leaders a veto over appointees, and more effective by giving them adequate resources, and full powers to investigate allegations of violations and to penalize violators.  (Go to Corporate Responsibility Campaign for details about Democracy Watch's proposals)

Bloc Québécois - B-
- "Le Bloc Québécois considère qu'un processus formel d'examen des nominations des hauts fonctionnaires et des dirigeants de sociétés d'État doit être une priorité du nouveau gouvernement. Les comités parlementaires doivent être au cœur du processus décisionnel et aucune nomination ne devrait être effectuée contre l'avis des comités." (p.31)
- "Le Bloc Québécois continuera de travailler à dépolitiser le processus de nomination des juges." (p.33)

Conservative Party - B-
- "A Conservative government will: - Ensure that all Officers of Parliament are appointed through consultation with all parties in the House of Commons and confirmed through a secret ballot of all Members of Parliament, not just named by the Prime Minister. This appointment process will cover: - The Ethics Commissioner - The Auditor General - The Chief Electoral Officer - The Information Commissioner - The Privacy Commissioner - The Registrar of Lobbyists -- Establish a Public Appointments Commission to set merit-based requirements for appointments to government boards, commissions, and agencies, to ensure that competitions for posts are widely publicized and fairly conducted. -- Prevent ministerial aides and other political appointees receiving favoured treatment when applying for public service positions." (p.9)

Green Party - B-
- "172. Create a Government Accountability Act to ensure that all those who monitor government are selected at arms length from those they monitor, and to guarantee transparency and openness for all government activities." (p.29)
- "181. Reinforce the political independence of public sector employees - especially scientists and professionals with responsibility for such areas as fisheries science and drug licensing." (p.29)
- "183. Reform the appointments system to discourage patronage." (p.29)

Liberal Party -  I
- Nothing related to proposal in platform

New Democrat Party - B
- "Make appointments on merit, not on political connections." (p.24)
- "Ensure that prior to the appointment of Supreme Court Judges, an independent committee would provide the House of Commons Justice Committee with criteria for examination and debate. Judicial appointments would be measured against public criteria." (p.25)
- "End abuses in the appointment of other public officials by: - Converting more Governor-in-Council (GIC) appointments to normal public service positions. - Establishing an independent advisory committee to develop criteria for GIC appointments and to act as a central clearing house for appointment recommendations to the Prime Minister and responsible Ministers. - Requiring approval by Parliamentary Committees of appointments of senior officers and board members of government agencies and Crown Corporations." (p.25)
- "Bring balance to the Canadian International Trade Tribunal to include the interests of workers and communities as well as businesses." (p.29)
- "Strengthen Canada’s homegrown film and television production by: - Reviewing and restructuring the CRTC to avoid the mixed mandates and conflicts of interest that undermine the role of the commission in promoting and protecting Canadian cultural industries." (p.32)
 

4. Ensuring loophole-free laws and strong penalties for wrongdoers - Close any technical and other loopholes that have been identified in laws, regulations, policies, codes, guidelines and rules (especially those regulating large corporations) to help ensure strong enforcement, and increase financial penalties for violations to a level that significantly effects the annual revenues/budget of the corporation.  (Go to Corporate Responsibility Campaign for details about Democracy Watch's proposals)

Bloc Québécois - B+
- "Le Bloc Québécois demande donc au gouvernement fédéral de négocier rapidement avec le Québec une entente qui permettra au Québec de se retirer avec pleine compensation de tous les programmes fédéraux de mise en œuvre de Kyoto, de façon à lui permettre d’appliquer des mesures appropriées sur son territoire pour lutter contre les changements climatiques." (p.47)
- "Pour que le Québec puisse participer au système des crédits compensatoires, ce qui est souhaitable, le Bloc Québécois demandera au gouvernement fédéral : - de revoir la cible des pétrolières qui est trop faible, comme nous l’avons expliqué plus haut; - de ne pas acheter lui-même des crédits, ni à l’étranger, ni aux organisations; - de renoncer à assumer une partie du coût des crédits que devront acheter les grands polluteurs pour se conformer à leur cible." (p.47)
- "Le Bloc Québécois propose également au gouvernement fédéral d’inscrire les crédits domestiques émis dans le cadre du Protocole de Kyoto à la Bourse de Montréal qui bénéficie déjà d’une expertise réputée dans les produits dérivés." (p.48)
- "Le Bloc Québécois demandera : - une réglementation sévère sur les normes de fabrication des véhicules qui prévoira de lourdes pénalités en cas de non respect; - l'élimination de la TPS sur l'achat de véhicules neufs consommant moins de 5 litres d’essence au 100 Km; - l’octroi de subventions à des organismes qui travaillent pour la lutte aux changements climatiques comme le CEVEQ; - la création d'une déduction fiscale sur les laissez-passer pour les transports en commun; - l’étiquetage écoénergétique obligatoire sur les véhicules neufs ou usagés vendus au Canada." (p.48)
- "Le Bloc Québécois exige que le gouvernement fédéral adopte une politique obligatoire d'étiquetage des OGM, qu'il ratifie le Protocole de Carthagène et qu'il établisse des zones de protection contre les semences OGM." (p.49)
- "Le Bloc Québécois presse le gouvernement fédéral de réviser ses positions dans les négociations commerciales pour faire en sorte d’inclure dans les accords commerciaux des clauses prévoyant le respect de règles minimales en terme de droit du travail, de respect des droits de la personne et de l’environnement." (p.78)
- "Le Bloc Québécois considère que le Canada, pour être crédible sur cette question, doit rapidement signer les grandes conventions de l'Organisation internationale du travail contre les discriminations, le travail forcé et le travail des enfants, pour le droit d'association syndicale et la libre négociation." (p.78)
- "Le Bloc Québécois demande des changements aux lois commerciales canadiennes pour permettre aux travailleurs de déposer des requêtes au Tribunal canadien du commerce extérieur. Il a d’ailleurs déjà déposé un projet de loi en ce sens." (p.78)
- "Le Bloc Québécois presse le gouvernement fédéral d'entamer rapidement des négociations avec les États-Unis et le Mexique pour voir à corriger les faiblesses de l'ALÉNA, notamment celles relatives au mécanisme de règlement des différends commerciaux." (p.79)
- "Le Bloc Québécois s'engage à poursuivre ses actions en vue d’augmenter l’encadrement des pétrolières notamment par un renforcement de la Loi sur la concurrence." (pp.79-80)
- "Le Bloc Québécois propose une majoration de l’actuelle surtaxe applicable à l’impôt des sociétés. Cette surtaxe ne viserait que les pétrolières et permettrait au gouvernement fédéral d’aller chercher près de 500 millions $ par année." (p.81)
 - "Le Bloc Québécois déposera à nouveau un projet de loi anti-briseurs de grève à la Chambre des communes et reviendra à la charge tant qu’il ne sera pas adopté." (p.115)
- "Le Bloc Québécois déposera à nouveau un projet de loi qui permettra aux Québécoises d’avoir des droits et une protection uniformes en cas de retraits préventifs." (p.116)
- ". . . Le Bloc Québécois est intervenu pour corriger la situation actuelle qui est déficiente et a appuyé pleinement le projet de loi C-55 qui instaure le Programme de protection des salaires, permettant ainsi aux travailleurs de récupérer une bonne partie du salaire auquel ils ont droit lors de la faillite de leur employeur. Le Bloc Québécois s’assurera, au cours de la prochaine législature, que ce programme soit instauré." (p.116)
- "Le Bloc Québécois s’engage à déposer de nouveau un projet de loi qui vient en aide aux victimes de harcèlement psychologique qui travaillent à l’intérieur de la fonction publique et celles qui sont régies par le Code canadien du travail." (p.116)
- "Le Bloc Québécois demande que soit remplacer le modèle existant d’équité salariale reposant sur des plaintes par une nouvelle loi distincte et proactive en matière d’équité salariale qui ferait de l’équité salariale un droit fondamental de la personne conformément à ce qui existe au Québec." (p.116)
- "Le Bloc Québécois propose que le gouvernement fédéral convie les différents intervenants liés à cette problématique à une rencontre pancanadienne afin de trouver des solutions durables à ce problème récurrent." (p.123)
- "Le Bloc Québécois continuera d’exiger l’abolition des dispositions de l’impôt sur le revenu qui permet aux entreprises canadiennes d’éviter de payer leur juste part d’impôt en s’établissant à la Barbade, un paradis fiscal." (p.126)
- "Le Bloc Québécois continuera à dénoncer l’entente fiscale Canada?Barbade, qui permet aux entreprises et aux individus canadiens de profiter de ce paradis fiscal pour échapper à leur devoir fiscal. . . . Le Bloc Québécois va déposer un projet de loi visant à annuler les modifications apportées à
l’article 250 (6) de la Loi de l’impôt sur le revenu." (p.126)
- "Afin d’amorcer dès maintenant un virage important en ce qui a trait à l’avenir du Saint-Laurent, le Bloc Québécois va mettre de l’avant les positions suivantes au cours des prochains mois : . . . - signer et mettre en œuvre la Convention internationale de 2004 pour le contrôle et la gestion des eaux de ballast et sédiments des navires." (p.137)
- "Le Bloc Québécois déposera un projet de loi obligeant le gouvernement à mettre en place une procédure d'examen pour les plaintes des citoyens relatives au bruit du transport ferroviaire et donnant à l'Office des transports le mandat de régler les différends pouvant survenir entre les sociétés ferroviaires et les sociétés de transport public." (p.158)
- "Le Bloc Québécois s’engage à déposer de nouveau ce projet de loi qui permet d’encourager les citoyens à utiliser les transports en commun et ainsi de réduire l’émission des gaz à effet de serre." (p.160)
- "Le Bloc Québécois favorise l'embauche d'inspecteurs itinérants par l'Agence canadienne d'inspection des aliments pour encadrer, et par là favoriser, la transformation à la ferme, qu'il s'agisse de l'abattage des animaux, de la fabrication de fromages ou autres. (p.165)
 - "Le Bloc Québécois réclame du gouvernement fédéral qu'il mette en œuvre les recommandations du rapport du Comité de pêches et océans adopté en juin 2002. Le rapport propose une approche plus agressive du Canada sur la scène internationale et en particulier au sein de l'Organisation des pêches de l'Atlantique nord-ouest (OPANO)." (p.174)
 - "Le Bloc Québécois continuera à combattre l’utilisation des pavillons de complaisance et pressera le gouvernement de ratifier la Convention des Nations Unies sur les conditions d’immatriculation des navires qui vise à limiter l’importance des pavillons de complaisance." (p.192)
- "Le Bloc Québécois a déjà déposé un projet de loi pour permettre à Ottawa d’empêcher une entreprise de poursuivre des activités qui provoquent des conflits ou des violations aux droits de la personne à l’étranger. Il s’engage à le faire à nouveau dans son prochain mandat." (p.194)

Conservative Party - C-
- "Restore the Canada Ports Police disbanded by the Liberals, which resulted in the growth of organized crime at Canada’s seaports." (p.25)
- "A Conservative government will: - Develop a Clean Air Act to legislate the reduction of smog-causing pollutants such as Nitrogen Oxides (NOx), Sulphur Dioxide (SO2), and particulate matter. - Address the issue of greenhouse gas emissions, such as carbon dioxide (CO2), with a made-in-Canada plan, emphasising new technologies, developed in concert with the provinces and in coordination with other major industrial countries. - Ensure water quality by addressing environmental issues such as the need for aquifer mapping, protection of the Great Lakes Basin, banning interbasin water transfers, imposing substantial penalties for illegal bilge oil dumping, and ensuring adequate watershed management and methods to ensure water quality and quantity. - Clean up federal contaminated sites and encourage the private sector to clean up brownfields. - Require 5 percent average renewable content in Canadian gasoline and diesel fuel, such as ethanol and
biodiesel, by 2010." (p.37)

Green Party - B+
- "3. Make industry accountable for its chemicals and impose significant pollution taxes on harmful chemicals until they can be eliminated. 4. Regulate chemicals in consumer products through the Canadian Environmental Protection Act (CEPA). 5. Mandate a CEPA taskforce to focus on pollution reduction in the Great Lakes basin. 7. Re-focus the Canadian Environmental Protection Act on pollution prevention. 8. Ban the incineration of imported toxic waste." (p.5)
- "9. Enact product stewardship legislation that would require wood producers to increase the life span of their products and to assume the full recycling and disposal costs of products. 10. Work with provinces, First Nations and the logging industry to create federal standards and best practices that ensure the sustainability of our forests. 12. In collaboration with the provinces and territories, pursue Forest Stewardship Council (FSC) certification of all forestry conditional upon compliance to its 10 principles on crown lands and encourage the same on private lands." (p.6)
- "16. Stop any and all bulk water exports by renegotiating or saying no to trade deals that allow corporations to strip our watersheds of freshwater and disrupt
entire ecosystems. 17. Amend the Charter of Rights and Freedoms to enshrine the right of future Canadians to an ecological heritage that includes breathable air and drinkable water. 18. Restore ecosystem health to Canada's coastline and inland watersheds by funding improvements to municipal wastewater treatment systems, with particular emphasis on ensuring shoreline communities and industries stop dumping untreated waste into rivers, lakes and oceans." (p.7)
- "19. Rescind all uranium-mining permits and prohibit the export of fissionable nuclear material. 20. Promote life-cycle product stewardship of metals to ensure that once mined, they remain in economic service for generations. 21. End all subsidies to the mining sector to ensure full-cost accounting. 22. Work with provinces, territories and industry to ensure that all mining operations are insured for environmental liabilities and have an adequate pre-funded plan for remediation when the mine closes. 23. Introduce and regulate the mining industry under an International Corporate Social Responsibility Act." (p.8)
- "34. Shift taxes on fossil fuels to earlier stages in the production cycle to encourage competition among companies to lower operating costs while reducing emissions. 35. Increase emission reduction targets for large industrial emitters to at least 55 Megatonnes above and beyond other policies and measures that reduce
industrial emissions. 36. Targets should be based on actual emissions, not emissions intensity per unit of production, and all data should be available for public scrutiny. 37. Expand the proposed National Emissions Trading System so that it will ensure real emission reductions across sectors. 38. Use revenue from tradable pollution permits to offset tax breaks for increasing energy efficiency and industry initiatives that reduce fuel consumption." (pp.9-10)
- "43. Legislate stronger, more effective antitrust laws in concentrated industry sectors." (p.11)
- "46. Sign and implement the Cartagena Protocol on Biosafety, ensuring that the adoption of new products is guided by the precautionary principle, which balances the economic benefits of innovation with public health and ecological integrity. 47. Strengthen and enforce Canada's Species at Risk Act in partnership with the provinces and territories to protect all species at risk and their habitats." (p.12)
- "53. Ban bottom dragging and lead efforts for a global ban on harmful fishing practices." (p.12)
- "54. Support local, provincial and territorial genetically engineered free zones and pass legislation requiring labeling of genetically engineered foods." (p.12)
- "58. Reform the regulatory environment of agriculture to challenge corporate concentration, eliminate international dumping and subsidies, and continue to allow seed saving by farmers." (p.13)
- "63. Pass a law that forbids the patenting of life forms and makes biotech developers of genetically engineered crops liable for damage such crops might cause." (p.13)
- "71. Enforce a mandatory target of 25 per cent better fuel efficiency for the automobile industry and increase standards over the next 5 years." (p.14)
- "84. Develop tax incentives for companies to meet the highest standards of gender and pay equity. 86. Implement full pay equity for women employed in the federal sector. 87. Sign the UN's global initiative for the elimination of discrimination and violence against women, and review Canada's performance to ensure it becomes and remains a world leader in fighting discrimination and violence against women. 90. Make eliminating institutional racism a top priority of Status of Women Canada's strategy to end violence and abuse facing Aboriginal women. 92. Mandate the CRTC to regulate and receive complaints about the advertising industry." (pp.17-18)
- "121. Use the full force of the Canada Health Act, federal spending power and the notwithstanding clause of the Charter of Rights and Freedoms to oppose any steps that open the way to two-tier health care in Canada." (p.23)
- "128. Provide incentives for companies to reduce stress in the workplace and promote emotional health. 129. Increase taxes on tobacco products, alcohol and junk food. 130. Rapidly reduce the release of carcinogens, mutagens, neurotoxins and endocrine-disrupting chemicals into the food chain. 131. Introduce mandatory labelling of all foods containing genetically modified organisms. 132. Ban the sub-therapeutic use of agricultural antibiotics and hormones. 137. Ban all non-natural pesticides and insecticides by the year 2010 and provide alternatives for farmers. 141. Prohibit reproductive cloning and require a Health Canada license for any organization or institution that performs genetic manipulation for commercial or scientific purposes." (p.24)
- "147. Create a "Comprehensive Anti-Poverty Strategy for Canada," which will: - Toughen regulations to ensure fair treatment and better wage standards for all working Canadians. . . 149. Enforce measures to ensure that corporate pension plans are adequately funded. 151. Create tax incentives for businesses to implement flexible schedules and on-site childcare. 152. Implement a managed reduction in the standard workweek to thirty-five work hours per week. 158. Combat racism in hiring practices and give greater recognition to foreign qualifications." (pp.25-26)
- "194. Close all loopholes that permit the establishment of offshore tax havens by Canadian companies." (p.31)
- "206. Support the provision of royalty-free and low-cost AIDS medicines for Africa, Asia and South America." (p.33)
- "207. Work with other nations to eliminate unsustainable fishing in international waters and create a system of marine sanctuaries. Press for custodial management of fish stocks on the Grand Banks." (p.33)
- "209. Work to increase the influence of the International Court of Justice." (p.33)
- "215. Renegotiate our multilateral trade agreements, such as NAFTA and the upcoming FTAA, to include fair trade tariffs that work to protect human rights and our ecosystems, as well as terminate investor-state dispute mechanisms that erode Canada's sovereignty and environmental laws. 216. Propose a reform of the WTO, the IMF and the World Bank, placing these institutions under the authority of the UN general assembly, and shift the direction of international trade away from "free trade" to "fair trade" focusing on the global protection of human rights, labour standards, cultural diversity, and ecosystems." (p.34)

Liberal Party - C
- "Positioning Canada in Global Business Networks: The Liberal government will invest almost $500 million over the next five years to implement CAN-Trade, a comprehensive network of services and programs. This new trade promotion strategy will better position Canadian firms, particularly small and medium-sized enterprises, in China, India and other priority markets. Highlights include: . . . - A Corporate Social Responsibility Centre which, in partnership with the private sector, will help ensure that Canadian activities in emerging markets foster social and environmental as well as economic goals; and - The Sustainable Cities Initiative, which links Canadian companies to opportunities for improving the sustainability of major cities in developing nations." (pp.47-48)
- "In April 2005, the Martin government released Moving Forward on Climate Change which details an ambitious strategy to meet Canada’s Kyoto protocol commitments by reducing “greenhouse gases,” like CO2 and methane, that are the main culprits behind global warming. Key measures include: - The Climate Fund - A $1 billion market-based institution will buy “emission reduction credits” from businesses, farmers, and others who invest to cut greenhouse gas generation in their activities. - The Partnership Fund, which will allow us to work with provinces and territories to meet our climate change objectives through support for large strategic projects that result in significant emission reductions. Funding of $2 to $3 billion will be made available over 10 years. - Regulatory measures that will establish “caps” on emissions by large industries and a 25% reduction target for automakers." (p.65)
 - "CLEAN AIR: Our climate change plan is improving air quality across Canada, with associated benefits for health and quality of life. A Liberal government will do more to ensure clean air through the following measures: - Monitoring and standards - Expand air quality monitoring and reporting through the new Air Quality Index. It will provide Canadians with the information needed to protect their health. We will complement this by developing national air emission standards for smog-forming pollutants and toxic emissions and will work with the US to upgrade our joint air quality agreement. We will also lead the way in the UN Environmental Program initiative to develop a Global Mercury Reduction Agreement with key countries such as China. - Renewable fuels standard - Introduce in cooperation with provinces and territories, a National Renewable Fuels Standard requiring, within five years, an average 5% renewable fuels content (e.g., biofuels like ethanol) in all gasoline and diesel fuel sold in Canada. We will maintain the excise tax exemption for biofuels. This initiative will contribute to cleaner air while stimulating a new biofuels industry in Canada and creating an important new market for farmers. CLEAN WATER: The National Ecosystem Initiative and Revitalization Plan: A Liberal government, supported by the provinces, banned the bulk removal of water from Canada’s watersheds. Those watersheds require our on-going stewardship. If re-elected, a Liberal government will implement a 10-year, $1 billion National Ecosystem Initiative and Revitalization Plan. The Plan covers the world’s largest freshwater ecosystem, the Great Lakes-St. Lawrence River basin, as well as other key waterways under stress, including the Lake Winnipeg watershed. It will include actions to identify and restore the significantly threatened ecosystems that incorporate our waterways. These ecological systems are home to well over half of Canada’s population and generate 75 per cent of Canada’s manufacturing output and 25 per cent of agricultural activity. The National Ecosystem Initiative builds on federal, provincial, and municipal sharedcost programs such as the Great Lakes Action Plan and the St.Lawrence Action Plan. While these initiatives have made a significant difference in many areas, more needs to be done to deal with key threats to our foremost ecosystems. The National Ecosystem Initiative will restore the areas contaminated by past actions - such as industrial toxins in the water and sediment, lost habitat, contaminated fish and wildlife - and keep pace with growth and development by addressing increased discharges from a higher population, intensive agricultural use, and new challenges such as nonpoint source contamination from the use of pharmaceuticals. The government will continue to address point-source pollution from industrial discharges into the water through federal regulations such as Canadian Environmental Protection Act and the Fisheries Act." (pp.66-67)
- "The Montreal Action Plan on Climate Change: The Liberal government invited the world to Canada as the host of the recently concluded United Nations Conference on Climate Change: Montreal 2005, because it understands that Canada must assume its international responsibilities if we are to address the environmental challenges that face this country and the world as a whole. This successful conference brought together over 180 countries to create the Montreal Action Plan, a road map for the world’s future approach to cooperation on climate change. As Canada’s Presidency of the United Nations Framework Convention on Climate Change continues through 2006, a Liberal government would lead the implementation of this plan." (p.68)

New Democrat Party - B+
- "Cut wasteful and inefficient spending on tax giveaways to large corporations, where those funds are given away without requiring that a single job be created, a single person trained, or a single dollar invested. We will stop the $10 billion in waste in this area proposed by the Liberals in their November 2005 election platform “economic statement”." (p.4)
- "Stop further privatization and protect public health care from being dismantled and privatized. (p.10)
- "Beginning by phasing out the evergreening of patent drugs so cheaper generic drugs can come to market sooner. And the ban on direct-to-consumer advertising of pharmaceuticals so there is less unnecessary prescribing of drug therapies." (p.12)
- "Jack Layton and the NDP will work to introduce and pass three major laws that will crack down on big polluters and help guarantee a cleaner environment for current and future generations. - Clean Water Act: to establish national standards and protection for drinking water, including those jurisdictions under federal control such as First Nations reserves. Water quality regulations under this law would include standards for solid waste disposal, dump management, mine site operations and rehabilitation, forestry and farming practices, and pesticide use. - Clean Air Act: to set and pursue a target that lives up to our responsibilities to the Kyoto Accord to address air pollution. . . . The NDP’s Clean Air Act will undo the damage caused by Liberal neglect and set a firm target ? by 2020, Canada’s greenhouse gas emissions will be 25% below what they were in 1990. - Polluter Pay and Toxic Pollution Reduction Act: to overhaul the Canadian Environmental Protection Act ? Canada’s national pollution law ? to introduce the polluter pays concept and to replace the current emphasis on voluntary action with mandatory pollution prevention measures." (p.13)
- "Fight smog by implementing a green car strategy: . . . ? Establish mandatory vehicle emission standards, opposed by the Liberals, applicable to all vehicles and modeled on the tough California emissions standards." (p.17)
- "Require all new appliances sold in Canada to meet the Energy Star standard." (p.17)
- "Protect the moratorium against drilling for oil off the coast of British Columbia, and oppose drilling for oil in the Great Lakes." (p.17)
- "We favour respecting consumers’ right to know through mandatory labelling of genetically modified organisms (GMOs)." (p.19)
- "Reassert strong leadership on Great Lakes protection issues, beginning with a strong position on the re-negotiation with the United States of the Great Lakes Water Quality Agreement." (p.19)
- "Commit to sustaining Canada’s ancient forests for future generations. The NDP will work with provincial and territorial governments, stakeholders, forest communities, First Nations, and environmentalists to protect Canada’s large intact forests (such as the Boreal Forest) and include adequate preserves, and that sustainable forest management be practiced." (p.19)
- "Improve Canada’s environmental rules regarding endangered species so that politics does not trump best available science when it comes to our responsibility for species that are at risk." (p.19)
- "Transforming NAFTA in order to achieve a fair trade policy. Deeper economic integration with the United States is not working for Canada. In light of recent and on-going trade disputes, the time has come for the parties to NAFTA to take a new look at the treaty, and to find ways to make it work in the cause of fair trade. We favour elimination of Chapter 11 (which, in our view, unreasonably limits Canada’s sovereignty in regulating investment). We also favour changes to address the serious shortcomings of the treaty provisions on energy and water. These issues require a broad consensus ? and there is a striking consensus emerging about them across Canada. To build on this growing consensus, we favour a public review of every aspect of the impact of NAFTA on the Canadian economy and Canadian public policy including tariffs, dispute resolution, energy, corporate regulation and ownership and culture." (p.28)
- "Bring balance to the Canadian International Trade Tribunal to include the interests of workers and communities as well as businesses." (p.29)
- "Working with farmers to ensure the right to save and reuse seed. The right to reuse seed will be a fundamental principle of Canada’s international aid development." (p.29)
- "Ensure fair wages and working standards, including: ? Increasing the minimum wage to $10 an hour for workers under federal jurisdiction. - As an important step towards fairness for women, implementing the recommendations in the Pay Equity Task Force Final Report. - Implementing federal laws to outlaw replacement workers in strikes or lockouts in areas of federal jurisdiction, something the Liberals oppose." (p.31)
- "Introduce legislation to create an independent watchdog on oil and gas prices that will report to Parliament, to help protect against future gouging by the big gas and oil companies." (p.31)
- "Strengthen Canada’s homegrown film and television production by: - Directing the CRTC to require clear, binding, monitored and enforced performance standards for broadcasters, including a significant and permanent increase in the production and broadcast of Canadian drama." (p.32)
- "Protecting pensions by: - Implementing a pension benefits insurance system for employees under federal jurisdiction, and invite provincial and territorial governments to join the system. - Building on the success of the NDP’s Wage Earner Protection Act (Bill C-55) and introduce amendments to Canada’s bankruptcy laws to put the economic interests of workers first. This would give both severance pay and unfunded pension liabilities priority in the allocation of corporate assets in bankruptcy. - Ensuring that workers’ pensions are protected by introducing changes to eliminate the practice of employer-contribution holidays and to tighten the rules to prevent employer underfunding of pension plans." (p.37)
 

5. Exposing corporate wrongdoing - Require all federally regulated corporations to disclose all convictions and settlements for violations of laws, regulations, policies, codes, guidelines or rules on an easily accessible, searchable, government-maintained website, so that consumers and investors can more easily make fully informed choices in the marketplace.  (Go to Corporate Responsibility Campaign for details about Democracy Watch's proposals)

Bloc Québécois - I
- Nothing related to proposal in platform

Conservative Party - I
- Nothing related to proposal in platform

Green Party - I
- Nothing related to proposal in platform

Liberal Party -  I
- Nothing related to proposal in platform

New Democrat Party - I
- Nothing related to proposal in platform
 

6. Penalizing corporate wrongdoing - Prohibit all corporations that violate domestic or international laws, regulations, policies, codes, guidelines or rules from receiving any federal government contracts, grants, subsidies, investments, customs/trade status, tax credits or deductions.  (Go to Corporate Responsibility Campaign for details about Democracy Watch's proposals)

Bloc Québécois - I
- Nothing related to proposal in platform

Conservative Party - F-
- "A Conservative government will: - Retain tax incentives such as the super flow-through share program. These measures are critical to Canada’s vibrant and effective financial market for mining. - Streamline regulatory processes related to the mining industry. We will implement the recommendations of the External Advisory Committee on Smart Regulation related to mining, such as a “single window” approach to federal regulatory bodies in the North for the oil and gas and mining sectors." (p.19)

Green Party - B
- "3. Make industry accountable for its chemicals and impose significant pollution taxes on harmful chemicals until they can be eliminated." (p.5)
- "21. End all subsidies to the mining sector to ensure full-cost accounting." (p.8)
- "24. End all federal subsidies to fossil fuel sectors and discontinue exploration, drilling and extraction in ecologically sensitive areas." (p.8)
- "34. Shift taxes on fossil fuels to earlier stages in the production cycle to encourage competition among companies to lower operating costs while reducing emissions. 38. Use revenue from tradable pollution permits to offset tax breaks for increasing energy efficiency and industry initiatives that reduce fuel consumption." (pp.9-10)
- "40. Begin a partial, gradual, revenue neutral tax shift from income, consumption and business taxes to resource use taxes, pollution taxes and land value levies reflecting corporate profits. 41. Review the Green tax shift every 3 years in order to monitor progress and readjust fiscal imbalances." (p.11)
 - "57. Shift government-supported research away from biotechnology and energyintensive farming and toward organic food production." (p.13)
- "99. Toughen the regulations governing the practices of immigration consultants; ensure enforcement and increase penalties for those convicted of human smuggling." (p.19)
- "128. Provide incentives for companies to reduce stress in the workplace and promote emotional health. 129. Increase taxes on tobacco products, alcohol and junk food." (p.24)

Liberal Party -  I
- Nothing related to proposal in platform

New Democrat Party - B
- "Establish a national energy retrofit program for residential, commercial, industrial and government buildings based on successful models used by local and provincial governments. In this proven job-creating program, the government would contribute money up front, which would be repaid from energy savings in the future. - Introduce new building codes for homes and industrial, commercial and institutional buildings and provide financial incentives for the construction of buildings that meet these new codes. - Improve the energy efficiency of our transportation system: - Provide significantly increased federal funding for public transit, rail transport and rail passenger services, and low-impact transportation options including cycling and pedestrian facilities. - Require a phased-in substitution of Canadian ethanol from local inputs for non-renewable fuel sources to 10% of motor vehicle fuel by 2010 and target increases in reliance on biodiesel fuel." (p.17)
- "Fight smog by implementing a green car strategy. - Encourage the manufacturing of lower or zero-emission vehicles in Canada, the kind of new models we need to keep auto plants open. - Provide financial incentives for purchasers of alternative-fuel vehicles, support the development of a domestic market and domestic R&D and component production." (p.17)
 - "Provide financial incentives for energy production from solar, wind, water, biomass and other renewable sources for electricity production and from industrial co-generation and small-scale community facilities." (p.17)
- "Exercise federal government leadership and provide financial support for the establishment of an east-west power grid to assist provinces dependent on non-renewable energy to reduce their fossil fuel consumption and fight smog." (p.17)
- "Phase out subsidies for non-renewable energy production and consumption, and invest these public dollars into renewable energy sources all within a revenue-neutral framework." (p.17)
- "Provide no new federal financial support to nuclear power production." (p.17)
 

7. Ensuring effective whistleblower protection - Require everyone to report any violation of any law, regulation, policy, code, guideline or rule, and give all watchdog agencies for corporations (for example: CRTC, Financial Consumer Agency of Canada, Canadian Transportation Agency, Competition Bureau) full powers to protect anyone who reports a violation (so-called "whistleblowers") from retaliation, to investigate the alleged violation, and to reward whistleblowers whose allegations are proven to be true.  (Go to Corporate Responsibility Campaign for details about Democracy Watch's proposals)

Bloc Québécois - C
- "Le Bloc Québécois proposera d’améliorer le système de dénonciation des actes répréhensibles et la protection de dénonciateurs dans le secteur public en : - réclamant que le nouveau commissaire soit approuvé par les chefs de l’opposition; - s’assurant que le gouvernement n’ait pas la possibilité d’exclure les sociétés d'État, les fondations et tout autre organisme fédéral de l'application de la loi; - en accordant au commissaire plus de latitude afin de corriger le tort imposé aux dénonciateurs; - facilitant aux dénonciateurs l’accès aux tribunaux; - s’assurant que la nouvelle loi ne serve pas de prétexte au gouvernement pour restreindre le droit à l’accès à l’information." (p.28)

Conservative Party - I
- Nothing related to proposal in platform

Green Party - B-
- "175. Support effective whistle-blower protection for public and private sector employees." (p.29)

Liberal Party - D
- "A Paul Martin government will immediately submit Judge Gomery’s second report to a Parliamentary Committee for study and advice to the government and to Parliament." (p.77)
- A Liberal government will continue to explore the underpinnings of democratic renewal" (p.77)
- "In the coming year, a Liberal government will engage in dialogue with Canadians to define the values and principles they wish to see reflected in their democratic institutions." (p.77)

New Democrat Party - B+
- "Pass a new Protection of Whistleblowers Act, applicable to both the private and public sectors that: - Provides legal protection from reprisal for those who disclose wrongdoing internally or externally, including imposing fines and jail sentences against individuals who engage in reprisals. - Establishes a whistleblower officer selected by, and reporting to Parliament who has broad powers of investigation and reporting." (p.25)
 

8. Increasing bank accountability - Require banks and trust companies to prove that their service charges and credit card interest rates do not amount to gouging, to disclose details about their service, lending and investment activities so that discriminatory patterns can be revealed and corrected (as in the U.S. - this requirement must also be applied to the federal government's financial institutions such as the Business Development Bank of Canada (BDC), Export Development Canada, Techonology Partnerships Fund and the regional investment funds), and to prove that branch closures are justified; and don't allow any bank or trust company to grow larger through mergers or takeovers if their record is poor.   (Go to Bank Accountability Campaign for details about Democracy Watch's proposals)

Bloc Québécois - B-
- "Étant donné la concentration déjà très forte du secteur bancaire au Canada, le Bloc Québécois s’est opposé à toute fusion entre les grandes banques canadiennes, à moins qu’elles fassent la démonstration devant les comités parlementaires concernés que cela va dans le sens de l’intérêt public.  Le Bloc Québécois maintiendra cette position." (p.81)
 - "Le Bloc Québécois est déterminé à participer au vaste mouvement international visant à modifier la Loi sur les Accords de Bretton Woods et des accords connexes afin que ces accords incluent le respect des droits humains et sociaux comme faisant partie intégrante du mandat du Fonds monétaire international et de la Banque mondiale afin que l’élaboration des politiques de ces organismes tienne compte des effets de celles-ci sur les progrès ou les régressions du respect des droits humains." (p.186)

Conservative Party - I
- Nothing related to proposal in platform

Green Party - I
- Nothing related to proposal in platform

Liberal Party -  I
- Nothing related to proposal in platform

New Democrat Party - B-
- "Improving small business access to loans. Banks, a main provider of capital for small business activity, are currently unaccountable for their performance. The NDP supports performance requirements for bank loans, information on fees and service charges. We would add protections to ensure that access to loans is not denied because of the size of a business." (p.29)
- "Modifying the regulation of credit cards to address small business concerns over increasing fee levels charged for credit card acceptance." (p.29)


 Top

Top of Report Card

Top of Report Card Background Details

Democracy Watch homepage